snape and sirius as a possible future traitor

[finwitch]

No: HPFGUIDX 34884

--- In HPforGrownups at y..., "jrober4211" <midwife34 at a...> wrote:
> 
> Having trust in someone is one thing, but knowing whether that 
trust 
> is valid is quite another thing. I'm just saying enough clues have 
> been thrown out there in the previous books, that if JKR wanted to, 
> she could develope Sirius as a character who betrays Harry. 

Except that 'he betrayed Potters/murdered - no he didn't/he's Harry's 
godfather - no, he's a betrayer after all...  It's simply too much 
moving to and back!

We've had *trusted* ones to turn out as Evil (Quirrell, 
Scrabbers/Wormtail, Crouch/Moody)
Bad-seeming ones turn out to be not guilty (Draco, Sirius)
And Snape... well, he's a total 'sitting on the fence' to me. He 
might be looking after his own interests (being allied to Both LV and 
AD until another one wins so he'll be in the winning side, no matter 
which one wins OR truly loyal to either of them, betraying the 
other...) Can't tell which side Snape belongs to, IF he belongs in 
the first place!