Torn page (LOLLIPOPS removed, sadly)

rachelrenee1 rachelrenee1 at yahoo.com
Sat Feb 9 23:55:36 UTC 2002


No: HPFGUIDX 34963

Tabouli wrote:

> > Yeah, it did seem out of character for the usually stringently 
law-
> >abiding teacher-respecting book-revering Hermione.  I file this 
> >under "slightly dubious plot devices", because after all, Harry 
> >*needed* to find that page in her hand, didn't he?  Couldn't 
> >Hermione have taken notes on a separate piece of paper to be found 
> >instead?
 Then Cindy responded:

> I hope no one has mentioned this already, but I figure Hermione is 
> free to deface any book in the library because she is quite adept 
at 
> repairing things with magic.  Let's see.  She repaired broken glass 
> and Harry's glasses (I think).  Replacing a page in a book ought to 
> be child's play, right?

Ya know, after reading the preface of Quidditch Through the Ages, I 
am suprised Hermione was not severely bruised and battered about the 
head after defacing a library book in such a fashion!  Surly Madame 
Pince would have enchanted the book so that a page torn out would 
carry a heavy penalty!

Rachel





More information about the HPforGrownups archive