Dumbledore (Was:Could the Stone have been Not Destroyed?)

tex23236 jbryson at richmond.infi.net
Mon Feb 18 00:11:21 UTC 2002


No: HPFGUIDX 35382

--- In HPforGrownups at y..., "Kyli Wayment" <k_wayment at h...> wrote:

> that were going to try, and instead of stopping us, he just taught
us enough 
> to help. I don't think it was an accident that he let me find out
how the 
> mirror worked....."
>   So, that may mean exactly what comes to the brain, but, if yout
hink about 
> it, it kind of sounds like Dumbledore *knew* the Stone would be
gone after 
> by Voldemort, so he practically told Harry that he could get it.

FWIW,  D'dore has a lot of these "insights." Note he wasn't too 
surprisedabout  Trelawney's revelation, and even added some 
things himself -- like the connection between Scabbers and Harry, 
with the implications of having saved a wizard's life. I'm guessing 
Dumbledore himself is a pretty accomplished seer.  He just knows 
more than we see him finding out. Some could come from backstory, 
like hard facts about magical theory.  But how does he know exactly 
what to say to Harry and Hermione as he sends them on their way 
to save Sirius and Beaky, especially with a time loop involved?

I think Dumbledore knows how all this is going to come out, 
perhaps better than JKR does at the moment.

tex






More information about the HPforGrownups archive