Differences between US & UK editions
mjollner
mjollner at yahoo.com
Tue Feb 19 14:44:12 UTC 2002
No: HPFGUIDX 35457
Curious about the much ballyhooed differences between the US and UK
editions of the HP books, I recently ordered a set of four UK edition
paperbacks. I've had a bit of time now to peruse them, and what
surprises me is not the textual differences (more on that later), but
rather the artwork.
In the abstract, I prefer Mary GrandPre's illustrations on the US
books to those that decorate the UK editions. I do like her little
pen & ink drawings that decorate the first page of every chapter.
However, her warm-n-fuzzy pastel cover illustrations seem a little
too...how shall one say..."upbeat," perhaps? for the darker tone the
series is now taking. In particular, after reading the US GoF, I was
struck by how misleadingly cheerful the picture of Harry on the front
is, waving his wand over the Goblet of Fire, whereas in the book,
Harry doesn't smile much, and with good reason. I then looked at the
US PoA book again, and sure enough, the cover seems inappropriately
happy, with a smiling Harry and Hermione (whom I thought at first was
Ginny, since on my copy at least, her hair looks red) riding Buckbeak.
Compare these to the cover of UK PoA, with a terrified Hermione
clutching a determined, serious Harry taking Buckbeak to rescue
Sirius. Not to mention the cover of UK GoF and that awesome rendering
of the dragon. I got a very different, darker impression of the book
just from looking at that picture.
The difference between the illustrations for the various editions were
what really got my attention. I found the textual differences to be
mostly superficial, although I did notice a few corrections in my UK
GoF paperback - the Priori Incantatem order was fixed, as was
something Dumbledore says to Sirius and Snape after they shake hands
in the hospital, "...unless the few of us who know the truth stand
united, there is no hope for any of us." In my US hardcover edition,
it reads, "...unless the few of us who know the truth do not stand
united..." Quite a different meaning!
Others have mentioned recently ordering one set or the other of the
books to compare differences; anyone else struck by anything unusual?
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive