Serpensortia
jklb66
jklb66 at yahoo.com
Tue Feb 19 18:32:48 UTC 2002
No: HPFGUIDX 35475
Previous posts were speculating that Snape's "shrewd and calculating
look", after Harry spoke to the snake in "The Dueling Club" chapter
of CoS, suggest that Snape suspected Harry was a parselmouth and had
been testing him. I've always read that look to mean that Snape was
doing the exact same mental calculation that Ron and Hermione are
doing at that moment.
Heir of Slytherin on the loose + Harry is parselmouth = Everyone is
going to suspect Harry is the Heir of Slytherin
The difference, of course, is that Snape will ENJOY Harry's
discomfort when the whispering begins. If Snape had been trying to
prove Harry was a parselmouth, and had just succeeded, I would expect
a different look. Perhaps like the triumphant "gleam" he gets in PoA
when he figures out that Harry's "old parchment" is directions into
Hogsmeade.
So, why did Snape suggest "serpensortia" to Draco if not to test
Harry? Most of the curses, hexes, jinxes (whatever) that Draco
probably knows will actually DO something physical to Harry.
(Examples: jelly-legs, furnunculus, tarantallegra, etc.) Kid stuff.
But, as has been pointed out many times before, Snape prefers
psychological torture over physical torture every time. By telling
Draco to conjure a dangerous snake right in front of Harry, Snape
hopes to get the immense pleasure of watching Hary be terrorized.
IMO, the idea that Snape has done this so he can enjoy seeing Harry
frightened, seems reinforced by,
"'Don't move, Potter,' said Snape lazily, clearly enjoying the sight
of Harry standing motionless, eye to eye with the angry snake. 'I'll
get rid of it...'"
Not only is Snape enjoying the sight, but he is letting Harry know
that he, Snape, is in control of how long the terror will last-- more
psychological torture.
Last question, how did Snape know that Draco could
do "serpensortia"? Maybe it was always one of Lucius's favorites!
Although I like the ideas that it is a Slytherin favorite, or that
Snape taught it to Draco just as much.
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive