[HPforGrownups] Re: snape is a dufus

[Amanda Lewanski]

No: HPFGUIDX 32693

kiricat2001 wrote:

<a rather well-done defense of Snape, considering she's one of Those
People>

> Marianne, wondering whether she's developed a split personality.

No, dear, just improved taste.....

Seriously, I will point out again the contrast in how Sirius and Snape
treat the unconscious members of their party on Shrieking Shack
Night---Sirius lets the unconscious Snape float along and bob'n'scrape
against the ceiling; Snape conjures stretchers for the injured Ron,
out-cold Harry, and needing-to-be-restrained Sirius. Most everybody,
when I mention this, just blows it off for one reason or another, and it
certainly doesn't make him a candidate for Humanitarian of the Year, but
I think this is an interesting comparison.

--Amanda, who really doesn't hate Sirius, but who won't excuse him for a
joke that could have killed someone on the basis of his age


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]