Breaking into Snape's office
clio44a
clio at unicum.de
Sun Jan 6 14:48:59 UTC 2002
No: HPFGUIDX 32872
Couple of days ago Eloise posted something on security in Hogwarts.
That made me think about the time when Barty Crouch aka Mad-Eye Moody
breaks into Snape's office (same night as Harry goes into the
prefect's bathroom) in GoF.
I wonder what he actually wanted there. For Moody-the-paranoid it
would make sense to search the office of a known Ex-Death Eater. But
Moody is Crouch. So why would Crouch go into Snape's office?
Would he look for evidence if Snape is still on the Dark side? What
evidence would that be? I mean he can't hope to find Snape's old DE
mask in a drawer or a file labeled Spying for Ddore 1979-'81, can he?
I cannot imagine Snape would keep any material concerning his DE days
or his service to Ddore in his office. His office is not a particular
safe place. It was broken into by H/R/H in their second year and
Snape has student visitors in there, like Harry on occasion (not
voluntary, but he was there). He even leaves Ron and Harry alone in
there for 10 min in CoS. So secret files, DE toys or poisons can be
ruled out from being in the office, I think.
Maybe Croutch was looking for potion ingredients in the office. Snape
mentions gillyweed and boomslang skin to be stolen when he threatens
Harry with the Veritaserum in GoF. We know that boomslang skin is an
ingredient for Polyjuice Potion.
H/R/H were nicking boomslang skin from Snape in their 2nd year
because they couldn't get it from anywhere else, if I remember
correctly. Assuming Croutch brews his Polyjuice Potion himself, which
would hold a high risk for him to be discovered,why would he risk
stealing from Snape's stores? Snape would find out eventually that an
ingredient for Polyjuice Potion is missing, and Crouch can't afford
to give away any hints that there is somebody brewing Polyjuice
somewhere in the castle.
Crouch, unlike R/H/H could easily go to London to buy boomslang skin
without anybody questioning him about him going there. And while he
was there, why would he not buy complete Polyjuice Potion? Wouldn't
that be less risky than to brew it himself?
And another thought about Crouch breaking into Snape's office: Why
wouldn't he hide his tracks better? Snape says the door was ajar and
the torches lit. Wouldn't you use a lumos spell on your wand if you
were searching one's office at night? IMHO either Crouch felt
completely safe to search the office (had Ddore really given Moody
premission to do so?) or he wanted Snape to know someone was in his
office.
So what do you guys think he was really doing in Snape's office that
night?
Clio,
who always gets confused when she starts thinking about something too
hard
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive