Lupin and the Moon-a new line of thought
gte510i
gte510i at prism.gatech.edu
Tue Jan 8 03:24:26 UTC 2002
No: HPFGUIDX 32995
For the Past week or two I have been reading up on the discussion of
Lupin not turing into a werewolf until the cloud un-eclipsed the moon.
I've heard some interesting theories but I must admit that another
issue precedes this.
That is: Lupin says that the wolfsbane potion need to be taken
durring the week preceding the full moon. Why did he need to take it
that night?
It would seem that come nightfall he would have locked the door and
curled up in his office as a harmless wolf. He would have taken his
potion the previous 7 days.
Even if the full moon didn't show up until midnight, he wouldn't have
turned into a monster, because tonight was not a 'take your potion
night'.
Any thoughts?
catydid
who has had a lot of fun finding the idiosyncrosies in the cannon and
thrilled that most have been addressed here.
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive