Snape/Lily thought...

flower_fairy12 graceofmyheart at hotmail.com
Sat Jan 12 13:03:51 UTC 2002


No: HPFGUIDX 33304

> Marianne wrote:
> For all we know, Lily might have been extremely cruel to Young 
> Severus, and deliberately humiliated him in front of his peers once, or more 
> than once.  Having to be reminded of her and her boyfriend 
> every day would be torture. <<<

I just don't like the thought of the Snape/Lily, unrequited love 
thing. 

Do we ever actually hear anyone in the books call Lily names, or put 
her down in any way? We hear Snape slagging on James etc., but never 
Lily. But I don't think it is because he loved her, or ever liked 
her. Maybe she was just a quiet girl who never bothered anyone, so 
therefore, no one could really say anything against her.

Rosie






More information about the HPforGrownups archive