[HPforGrownups] Re: The Female Students (and other female charcters)

[Hollydaze]

No: HPFGUIDX 33420

Aja wrote:
> --Madame Maxine and the Beauxbatons students: presented more ?
> positively, but there is a very unflattering moment when all the 
> members of the girl's school summarily burst into tears after not 
> being chosen by the goblet to compete in the TWT.
<SNIP>
Actually only two of them did, and it is not a girls school it is mixed as harry notices both Boys and girls when they get out of the carriage.

> --Fleur: beautiful, but she comes across as a bit manipulative 
> because of her Veela looks and ancestry.  She is also presented as 
> the worst of the four tri-wizard competitors.
but as has been pointed out before most of this was not her fault.
All of the champions made mistakes in the first task. I think someone pointed out that JK has mentioned Grindylows as being native ONLY to the UK (hence why she got into trouble with them) (she performed the Bubble head charm pretty well, while Krum messed up his transfiguration) and in the 3rd task she was attacked by the Imperio Krum before she could do anything so we don't know how she would have done.


HOLLYDAZE!!!




[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]