The Female Students -Voldie underestimating women
cmf_usc
cmf_usc at yahoo.com
Tue Jan 15 23:34:04 UTC 2002
No: HPFGUIDX 33520
Hi all! Responding to Kimberly's really interesting analysis--
> Which brings to mind something positive that JKR has done in
respect to women. V discounts them, and quite to his detriment.
<snip great description of Mrs. Lestrange's strength>
>Perhaps if he'd sought to get her <(Mrs. Lestrange)> out of
> prison, he'd have had a loyal servant who didn't have the strangely
> counterproductive urge to teach Harry to resist the Imperious
> curse :D I love minor characters!
>
> Second woman he should've given more credit - Lily Potter, of
course!
> "Step aside woman!" is pretty dismissive. Too bad he didn't take
> into account her strength, her love, and her determination to
protect
> her child. I'm guessing that in the future this tendency to
discount
> the power and importance of women will bite him in his creepy
tush.
> I could see that happening with Hermione, McG, Molly... any of
> several women. Just something that popped into my head.
>
Somehow I never focused on this flaw of Voldemort's! But now that
Kimberly's spelled it out, I can see it might have a real bearing on
future plots. With Hermione especially--as a female and Muggle-born,
Voldie may really underestimate her in future.
Can't you just see it--- "I'm going to take over the world, and
there's nothing you can do to stop me, Muggle girl!" To which
Hermione replies, "But I read _Obscure Spells and Little-Known
Magic_ , and I know all I have to do is (fill in the blank)!"
This makes me worry about Hermione though--might she be the one who
is sacrificed while doing something dangerous? That might be kind of
unexpected, and we know how JKR likes surprises.
Caroline
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive