Hogwarts romances (some SHIP)

Penny & Bryce pennylin at swbell.net
Sat Jan 26 04:07:08 UTC 2002


No: HPFGUIDX 34092

Hi --

Last post of the night for me!

lucky_kari wrote:

> 

 We do know that it was very quickly out of Hogwarts because they were
> dead without a few years after being together for at least two years.

Huh?  Not sure what you mean here.  They were married for at least 2 yrs 
if they were married before conceiving Harry, but I can't figure out how 
you're calculating a marriage date soon after leaving Hogwarts.  We 
don't know how old they were when they got married or had Harry ... so I 
can't see as it's possible to calculate.

> Whether they completely got together at Hogwarts is a matter of
> debate, but it'd be stretching it, imho, to think it didn't start
> there.

Might have started there ... but there's not telling for sure what sort 
of interlude there might have been at Hogwarts.  Just flirting & they 
didn't get together until 1, 5 or 10 yrs after leaving Hogwarts?  That's 
as much a possibility as that they dated steadily at Hogwarts & married 
1 yr after leaving.  No evidence either way so equal possibilities in my 
mind.


> 
Add to that the absurdly young age
> Lily and James Potter were married at,

Again, huh?  Where's the canon evidence for this?  I know this is a 
common fanfic assumption but ...I don't recall anything in canon to 
support it.

Penny





More information about the HPforGrownups archive