Dumbledore's Death (?)

mrflynn6 mrflynn6 at yahoo.com
Mon Jul 1 12:03:58 UTC 2002


No: HPFGUIDX 40636

--- In HPforGrownups at y..., "talia_dawn_3" <TaliaDawn3 at a...> wrote:
>      I now have a theory which can be supported with canon.  (After 
> my Death Eater groupie theory was shot down, I've been working on 
> another one.)  I think that Dumbledore *will* die ... and Hagrid 
will 
> kill him.  
>      Now before all the Hagrid fans kill me, let me explain.  
> *Hagrid* is the one that keeps going on and on about how he's not 
> afraid as long as Dumbledore is there.  To me, the fact that people 
> keep saying that means that he is going to die.  That could just be 
> me over-infering, of course.  I think that Hagrid, whether by 
> accident or on *gasp* purpose will be the downfall of Albus 
> Dumbledore.  Why?  I suppose it will most likely be indirectly.
>      As we have seen (especially in PS/SS) Hagrid has a tendency to 
> tell people things that he shouldn't have.  He tells The Trio so 
much 
> about the Philosopher/Sorcerer's Stone.  He told Voldemort!Quirrel 
> how to get past Fluffy.  He told the Trio how to get past Fluffy (I 
> think....or do I have a case of movie poisoning again?).
>      I think that in one of the next books, Hagrid will tell 
someone 
> something and it will lead to the death of Dumbledore.  Let's say 
> that there is a plan to trap Voldemort.  Hagrid accidentally lets 
it 
> slip where/when it will take place.  The Death Eater/evil person he 
> told it to tells Voldemort.  Voldemort is therefore ready and kills 
> Dumbledore when he trys.
>     Hence Hagrid killed Dumbledore.
> 
> ~*~*~* Talia Dawn *~*~*~



I have also wondered about this.  How many times has Dumbledore 
said "I would trust Hagrid with my life."  My other theory relating 
to this subject is that the pink umbrella will surface to SAVE 
Dumbledore's life.  Not being a fully qualified wizard, it would be a 
surprise to everyone if Hagrid were to save Dumbledore 
with "advanced" magic, perhaps leading to him being able to practice 
magic?

Gretchen





More information about the HPforGrownups archive