another Arther Weasley question

tmarends tmarends at yahoo.com
Sat Jul 6 05:00:56 UTC 2002


No: HPFGUIDX 40845

Gretchen wrote:
> 
> In re-reading GoF, a line hit me that I did not notice before.  On 
> Page 203 of the US hardcover version, Malfoy is reading Harry and 
Ron 
> an article from the Daily Prophet about Arthur Weasley at Moody's 
and 
> the dustbins.  Malfoy was commenting on how they got Arthur's name 
> wrong in the article saying "imagine them not even getting his name 
> right, Weasley. It's almost as thought he's a complete nonentity, 
> isn't it?"  Is he a nonentity?  It was suggested he was an 
> unmentionable-maybe he is, but uses another name for the sake of 
his 
> family.  Maybe he changed his name for other reasons?  Could this 
be 
> a "clue" into Arthur's past?
> 

OK, so the Daily Prophet gets things wrong.  Especially if they are 
written by Rita Skeeter.  But COULD Ms. Skeeter have not been there 
for the story and was just relaying it, and heard Mr. Weasley was 
involved, but automatically assumed it was Arthur's twin brother 
Arnold?  I mean, twins do run in families.  Maybe the twin brother 
Arnold is an unmentionable, and stays out of sight, but every other 
wizard of any importance would know there was a Weasley set of 
twins.  Right??

Tim A.






More information about the HPforGrownups archive