YES! The Great Alchemist Debate Solved (sort of)

[dorbandb]

No: HPFGUIDX 41113

--- In HPforGrownups at y..., "dorbandb" <dorbandb at y...> wrote:

  Anyone who has the technology and has seen Flamel's 
> card is welcome and encouraged to share that info.  Thanks,
> 
> Brian

This new info from our sister group:

--- In HPFGU-Movie at y..., "alhewison" <Ali at z...> wrote:

> The deleted scene shows Ron toss Dumbledore's card at Harry. Harry 
> then reads it, and just as the book finds Flamel mentioned as 
> Dumbledore's alchemist partner. There is no separate Flamel card 
> shown on the DVD at all. Unfortunately, this does not provide any 
> further info on Flamel's Wizard/Muggle status.
> 
> Ali
> 
> (who bought a DVD player specially to play the DVD and is happy but 
> broke!)

Thank you Ali!  You're right, it doesn't provide any further info, but 
that's OK as I would have been a little peeved if suddenly Flamel had 
a wizard card in the quasi-canonical dvd and nowhere else.  It is much 
better that this situation is still ambiguous within the accepted 
canon.  Thanks for your help...er, sorry ya' went broke :(

Brian