Barty Jr and the Dementor

[greg_a126]

No: HPFGUIDX 41523

--- In HPforGrownups at y..., "soror_avo" <sororavo at a...> wrote:
> I somehow wonder if we are being mislead again.  Voldemort states 
> that the one who has been most faithful will have the greatest 
> reward. Later, Dumbledore tells Fudge the dementors must be removed 
> from Azkaban as they are Voldemort's most loyal supporters.
> 
> Fudge comes with a dementor at his side - it got there quickly 
didn't 
> it?  Perhaps the real reason Fudge is so nervous is he doesn't want 
> to get caught - that Barty has NOT lost his soul, but has been 
taken, 
> whole, to Voldemort's side - which means we could expect that Barty 
> will be appearing again...and obviously it will have to be as 
someone 
> else - possibly someone that could undermine Harry, little bits at 
a 
> time.
> 
> Thoughts?
> 
> Kathy

Yeah, But Professor McGonagall was in the room when the dementor gave 
Barty Jr. the Kiss.  & the emotion she showed in the hospital wing, 
first the anger & then the color draining from her face implies to me 
she really remembered it happening, rather than a memory Fudge may 
have implanted into her head, so Barty's as good as dead.