Hogwarts is not Unplottable (WAS Re: Hogsmeade and unplottable Hogwarts)
xp39c
xp39c at yahoo.com
Fri Jul 26 22:09:23 UTC 2002
No: HPFGUIDX 41772
Lara wrote:>>>>>>>>
"If anyone can get to Hogwarts, via hogsmeade, then what's the point
in making Hogwarts unplottable? So my question is: does it state
anywhere that Hogwarts is unplottable? ">>>>>>>>
then Lizbot wrote:
>"I just looked this up on the HP Lexicon:
> "Unplottable
>
> incantation not given
>
> A magical effect on a place; makes it impossible to plot its
location
> on a map.
>
> Hermione suggested that this may have been done to make Durmstrang
> and Beauxbatons harder to locate by other witches and wizards.
(GF10)
> Hogwarts also has wards and spells on it to hide its true nature
from
> Muggles, but it is apparently not Unplottable."
>
> So that's what the Lexicon has to say about unplottableness (new
> word). I don't have my books with me to check, but I'm inclined to
> always trust the Lexicon.
I think that Hogwarts is one of those special places that has both
plottable and unplottable properties. It is plottable because
Muggles can find the place and put it on a map; however, to Muggles
Hogwarts appear to be merely castle ruins. It is unplottable
because, as Hermione said about 500 times, one can't apparate or
disapparate from the place.
--Hei Lun
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive