Doomed, they're Doomed!

errolowl nithya_rachel at hotmail.com
Sun Jun 2 02:18:22 UTC 2002


No: HPFGUIDX 39321

 Penny wrote:

> Pip gave us an analysis of the likelihood of death & doom for 
various characters --I agree that Hagrid & Dumbledore are both 
DOOMED ..... they both definitely have the DOOMED target on their 
backs.  :::nods::: 

> Sirius -- No!  No, no, no.  :::falls to her knees & pleads with 
JKR::::  No...no....


Sorry to be a pessimist Penny, but IMO Sirius has DOOMED stamped 
across all his `Wanted' posters
.*How* else is he going
to be redeemed in the eyes of the WW ?  "ooooh! That evil mass 
murderer was actually the martyr that helped save us all
gave his 
life to protect Harry Potter, he did! (he *does* have that tendency, 
now) 
..poor, misunderstood, unjustly maligned public enemy no.1 (ehm, make 
that 2). He was a hero all along – let's give
him a posthumous medal" has somewhat more oomph than a  general 
announcement saying `oh, by the way see, we were wrong –
Black is
just another nice guy'. That just doesn't begin to cut it. 

So unless there are some Bangy theories out there
..

Errol, who doesn't really believe it, but has that sinking
feeling anyway.







More information about the HPforGrownups archive