[HPforGrownups] Re: Lupin is an honest, nasty, DISLOYAL person (who is ever so evil)

[Charles Engle]

No: HPFGUIDX 39381


Pip said:
>>>> Like Moody he confiscates the Marauders Map. This is the 
only counter-argument atm, because surely he should know that 
it reveals true names. Or has he warned Moody to grab the map 
off Harry as soon as  possible?<<<

Problem: GoF 25 

"'Potter...' [Crouch!Moody] said slowly, ' you didn't happen, by any chance, to see who broke into Snape's office, did you?  On this map, I mean?'

'Er...yeah, I did...' Harry admitted.  'It was Mr. Crouch.'

Moody's magical eye whizzed over the entire surface of the map.  He looked suddenly alarmed."

Why, if he was told about the map by one of its co-creators, was he so surprised (or rather, alarmed) that his true identity had shown up?  It doesn't fit.

Also, this theory puts Lupin with Voldemort during Voldy's "dark times".  

" Surely, one of my faithful Death Eaters would try and find me... one of them would come and perform the magic I could not, to restore me to a body... but I waited in vain..." GoF  33.

Voldemort himself says that Quirrel was the first to come along.  Can you trust the bad guy?  In this case, I think so; for this is his triumphant "I expect you to die, Mr. Bond" speach.  Villains NEVER lie during these. 

Or do they?

 

Ish (who notices everyone else puts neat little phrases in parenthesis after their name)



---------------------------------
Do You Yahoo!?
Sign-up for Video Highlights of 2002 FIFA World Cup

[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]