Lupin is an honest, nasty, DISLOYAL person (who is evil)

[sparklin_red]

No: HPFGUIDX 39412

I am finally removing my self from the lurkerdom.  I have sat in the 
shadows reading comments and theories.  Every time I have had 
something to say someone has always beat me to it and rather than 
post a Me Too!!! comment I sit in the shadows thinking.

Well congratulation Pippin you're the first to get a comment out of 
me.

It will probably rather long because I have spent a graveyard shift 
at work thinking through what I was going to say

Pippin so eloquently wrote about the Dementors: 

~~ Think about it. There're been people wandering around the grounds 
all night. Snape, Fudge, MacNair, Dumbledore, Hagrid, Tt!Harry and Tt!
Hermione . The Dementors don't bother any of  them. Then all of a 
sudden there are hundreds. Why? Because werewolf!Lupin set the 
Dementors on our heroes. (shiver!) Can the Dementors tell when 
they're dealing with a human mind in a canid body? They can't. ~~

Okay here goes.

~* Cracks her knuckles to begin her typing *~

"Dementors are among the foulest creatures that walk the earth.  They 
infest the darkest, filthiest places, they glory in Decay and 
despair, ~they drain peace, hope, and happiness out of the air around 
them. ~" 
COS Chapter 10 The Marauder's Map page 187 American Version

And

" "I don't know how I did it," he said slowly.  "I think the only 
reason I never lost my mind is that I knew that I was innocent.  That 
wasn't a happy thought, so the Dementors couldn't suck it out of me
"
COS Chapter 19 The Servant of Lord Voldemort page 371 American 
Version 

Having added that I'll now begin attacking the suspects that appear 
to be left alone by the Dementors.

Fudge and MacNair:
I'll start with these two first they are the easiest.  Fudge and 
MacNair are very upset with the escape of Buckbeak.  Such a dangerous 
and uncontrollable beast running around out there free.  That is not 
a happy thought.  Nor is it peaceful or hopeful.

Dumbledore:
Two words.  No wait six words.
Dumbledore can take care of himself.

Tt!Harry and Tt!Hermione: 
They are worried about to quote Tt!Hermione (COS Hermione's Secret 
pg. 398 American Version)
"Don't you understand?  We're breaking one of the most important 
wizarding laws!  Nobody's supposed to change time, nobody!  You heard 
Dumbledore.."
You get the point.  Let's see. Happy nope, Peaceful nope, Hopeful 
nope, so not quite Dementor material.  

Snape:
Now this one I can only based off of my opinion.  But the way I see 
it is that Snape has just found out that (what he believes) Lupin has 
been helping Black all along.  He is upset that Dumbledore did not 
listen to him about Lupin couldn't be trusted.  Happy, Peace, or 
Hope, all three are negative.  Of course being a good sport I have to 
list the opposite of this theory.  That Snape is ecstatic because 
Lupin is a traitor.  My only response is that Snape could know how to 
defend himself from Dementors.

Hagrid:
~* Takes a moment to think *~
Hagrid is be ecstatic about Buckbeak escaping in fact he is "weak 
with happiness" page 402 COS Hermione's Secret.  Having stated that 
here is my explanation.  The Dementors do not actually show up until 
Harry is chasing the Snitch and Gryffindor was over 50 points up COS 
Grim Defeat pages 177-179.  So I believe that the Dementors felt 
Hagrids Happiness faintly due to the fact that it is him and 
Dumbledore that are happy about it and not the 100's of Hogwarts 
students at the Qudditch.  I believe they were zooming in on Hagrid 
and then Hagrid hear Moony's howl.  At that point Hagrid immediately 
began to worry for Buckbeak's safety. So bye bye Happiness.

Which at that point they began to Zoom in on
.

HARRY
Harry is Happy because he gets to leave the Dursleys and live with 
Sirius.  What is not Happy about that thought.

And SIRIUS
Sirius is thinking he gets to clear his name.  Never return to 
Azakaban again.  And Harry wants to live with him.  Happy Happy Very 
Happy thoughts. 

That means the Dementors were drawn to the only current happy 
thoughts on the ground.  Sirius and Harry.  They are not allowed in 
the castle so they can't focus on any there.  

One additional point for your Lupin is Evil plot.

 " Severus Snape was pulling off the Invisibility Cloak, his wand 
point directly at Lupin." 
COS Chapter 18 Moony, Wormtail, Padfoot, Prongs page 357 American 
Version

Why is Snape's wand pointed directly at Lupin and not at Sirius who 
is the escaped prisoner????

Congratulations once again Pippin.  Now that I am out I just won't 
stop.  That is until I run out of things to say which I have. 

Sparklin Red 
(Wonder how exactly you join LOON?)