TBAY: Neville and Foreshadowing

[jtdogberry]

No: HPFGUIDX 39479

Dogberry lies back and admires the latest catch having abandoned ship 
simple because it was going around in circles.

Ok, I confess to being stumped on to the why does Moody's lesson 
affect Neville more then the dementors, and yes, I agree it was just 
a slip of the tounge with the egg. Mayby it was a shock to see it 
performed for real again.
But I remain steadfast about Mrs Longbottom knowing Voldies 
whereabouts not her husband Frank (does anyone remember a childrens 
programme on the BBC many years ago, where it was some kids trying to 
hide this prof from the badies but the badies caught them and 
the "prof told them that the prof was not him but his wifeand so the 
badies were defeated) and I still say the is something fishy going on 
because of the way she is refered i.e. never by name.
Again, something is going one with his remaining reletives, either 
evil gran OR evil Algie. 

I think something is about to happen about Neville because re-reading 
GOF (UK paperback edition)because three times, Neville's work in 
class is mentioned. 
First MCgonagall lesson p208, "Longbottom, kindly do not reveal that 
can't even perform a simple switching spell in front of anyone from  
Durmstrang.  
Second, in Flitwicks class p260 "...he was given extra homework, the 
only person to get any apart from Neville".
Third, Mcgonagall again p336 "Neville's guinea pig still had feathers"

This has never happened before. JKR seems to be trying to make him as 
useless as possible.

Also, I think Percy's cauldron report is going to come into it, 
remember, he says leaking potons through crack in a thin bottom, he 
will know an awful lot about cauldron and what it would take to melt 
one, you just need to ask!!!

So where is this all going, I have no idea, I'm very confused. I am 
down to Neville being under a memory charm again with evil gran 
thrown in or  W.I.N.C.H.

Dogberry (who really doesn't belive that Mcgonagall is evil and 
neither is Lupin.)

> 
> For an explanation of the acronyms and theories in this post, visit
> Hypothetic Alley at 
> 
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/HPforGrownups/files/Admin20Files/hypoth
> eticalley.htm 
> 
> and Inish Alley at 
> http://groups.yahoo.com/group/HPforGrownups/database?
> method=reportRows&tbl=13