[HPforGrownups] Hogwarts, A History (was: Unanswered questions)

[Amanda Geist]

No: HPFGUIDX 39506

Amy said

> Marilyn flew in all the way from Mars (welcome!) to write:
>
> >But I was under the impression that all the copies were checked out
> >*because* people wanted to find out about the chamber
>
> I thought so too.  Maybe the rumor *did* make the rounds but hadn't
filtered
> to the 2nd-years yet.  Or they had them out for Binns but, unlike what
> Hermione suspected, were only reading the boring passages.

I had always thought that all the copies were removed from the library, to
keep down rampant speculation among the students. Nothing to base that on, I
just thought it made sense. That would explain the lack of books *and* the
lack of rumors about the Chamber.

--Amanda