Apparate or die trying

Brooks Rowlett brooksar at indy.net
Fri Jun 7 04:33:29 UTC 2002


No: HPFGUIDX 39536

OK:  Based on the first book, it seems pretty certain that
Dumbledore is  *flying* to London.  Just because you cannot apparate on or off 
of Hogwart's  grounds, doesn't mean he couldn't, say, walk to Hogsmeade and
apparate from THERE.

So must we assume that as great a wizard as AD is, *he* cannot
apparate, but must take broomstick or floo instead?

Frankly I think the bottom line of all this is that JKR adds ideas as she comes 
up with them, and doesn't think out that there are certain logical consequences 
that would reverberate through her world...  a phenomenon we have encountered a 
LOT in Star Trek, for example.

And.... you know....?

http://www.otmfan.com/ssclub/html/stopbook.htm
http://www.otmfan.com/realaudio/stopbooks.ram

  -Brooks A Rowlett







More information about the HPforGrownups archive