What *Really* is the Purpose of Transfiguration?
greg_a126
grega126 at aol.com
Tue Jun 11 01:27:24 UTC 2002
No: HPFGUIDX 39671
So far we've all read 4 Harry Potter books. Thus far, we've seen a
grand total of 3 uses of Transfiguration: the Animagus
Transfiguration, Cedric Diggory turning a rock into a dog during the
first task, and Victor Krum partially transfiguring himself into a
shark for the 2nd task. Just for comparison's sake, there were a
total of 4 champions, & through the first 2 tasks they used
transfiguration twice, & at least 6 different charms: a Sumoning
charm, whatever charm Fleur did to make the dragon fall asleep &
then a charm to put out the fire on her skirt, the Conjunctivitis
Curse (which I really think is just a specific type of a charm), the
Bubble-Head Charm & the charm that Harry used to get the Grindylows
to leave him alone.
And even in the bit of normal wizard life that we see when Harry
visits the Weasleys we never see anyone use Transfiguration. We see
Mrs. Weasley use tons of charms to cook & clean, but never
transfiguration. If they could, why wouldn't they use
Transfiguration all over the house to turn all of their old looking
stuff into new looking stuff.
Through 4 years of school, I've only seen the trio learn a single
bit of Transfiguration I'd like to know how to do, and that's the
very first one they learned. On occasion, buttons pop off & I can
never find a needle, but they learn how to make one w/ a match &
those are usually much easier to find. But from there, they just
learn more and more useless stuff. And Professor McGonagall on the
first day of the class they ever had showed them something that they
may one be able to do, turn their desk into a pig. I'm not sure
about anyone else out there, but really, I have never looked at my
desk & thought to myself, well that's fine and good, but what I
really need right now is a pig.
So I guess the real purpose of the last three paragraphs is this.
What really is the purpose of Transfiguration? The rest of the
classes I can understand. Charms is easy enough, they're used all
the time, DADA is obvious, Potions is easy to understand, Herbology
helps you identify the ingredients you need to find to make your
potions, History of Magic, well, "Those who don't know the past are
condemmened to repeat it." But as far as I can tell,
Transfiguration seems about useless. Write me back & tell me why
I'm wrong.
Greg
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive