What *Really* is the Purpose of Transfiguration?
barefootpuppets
heidi at barefootpuppets.com
Tue Jun 11 03:29:18 UTC 2002
No: HPFGUIDX 39674
Greg writes:
>>And even in the bit of normal wizard life that we see when Harry
visits the Weasleys we never see anyone use Transfiguration. We see
Mrs. Weasley use tons of charms to cook & clean, but never
transfiguration. If they could, why wouldn't they use
Transfiguration all over the house to turn all of their old looking
stuff into new looking stuff. <<
Hmmm...this is intersting. Why don't the Weasley's just transfigure
all of their stuff into newer/better stuff? The only thing I can
think of is that transfiguration is very difficult magic requiring a
lot of concentration, focus, and talent. It may be that the Weasley
parents aren't very talented in that department. It really may take
a very special hand. We know that MacGonagall is very well versed in
Transfiguration, but we see so many people struggling ("Your
pincushion still curls up whenever anyone comes near it with a pin"
and the like).
I would also surmise that they *have* to learn it for the same reason
that we *have* to learn all sorts of useless trivia in school. Do I
use trigonometry or calculus in my daily life? No. But, one cannot
discern one's area of talent (or level of talent) without exposure to
many different subjects/practices/whatever.
Heidi R.
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive