SHIP: Dobby/Winky
rosie
crana at ntlworld.com
Mon Jun 17 11:06:17 UTC 2002
No: HPFGUIDX 39974
I don't know if this has been suggested before, but what about Dobby/Winky?
They are the only house elves we actually know anything about, and while
they seem to have very different attitudes in GOF (Dobby loves freedom/Winky
thinks it's very shameful), now the Crouches are dead, maybe Winky will
loosen up a bit?
Even though Harry says its hard to tell the sex of house elves, they do seem
to have families etc - Winky talks about her mother and grandmother serving
the Crouches before her. Dobby seems to be a strapping young house elf
making his way ahead in the WW. Could his next stop be a lovely,
squashed-tomato-nose girlfriend?
They paired up to seek work - suggesting friendship, at least - and he
certainly seems very concerned about her: at the end of GOF, when Winky is
distraught, Dumbledore advises in a meaningful sort of way that Dobby will
probably look after her. Why Dobby? Assuming Winky knows any of the other
elves at Hogwarts yet, wouldn't her girl-elf friends be in a better position
to comfort her than Dobby, who Winky is always saying is "bad"?
Dobby is definitely someone who is very caring and protective (the Gillyweed
episode, the beautiful hand-knitted socks), and with Crouch Jnr out of the
picture, Winky needs someone to look after. She was used to a more personal
involvement with people than the rest of the house elves, who seem to just
cook and clean. Could Dobby and baby elves be the way ahead?
Rosie
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive