polyjuice question..

corinthum kkearney at students.miami.edu
Tue Jun 18 18:27:33 UTC 2002


No: HPFGUIDX 40032


Carrie-Ann wrote:

> I was wondering something about Polyjuice potion.  Here's the 
> scenario...
> Person A takes polyjuice with a hair of person B in it.  Now Person A 
> has transformed into person B.  Person C comes along, and thinking 
> that person A is really person B makes a polyjuice potion with 
> something from person A (in his transformed state). Now, my question 
> is... Who does person C turn in to?  


Perhaps person C would turn into person A turned into person B.  In
other words, they would take on the appearance of person B for the
remainder of person A's hour, and then turn "back" into person A for
the remainder of his or her own hour.  After all, if Polyjuice Potion
is able to detect every aspect of a person's appearance from just one
hair, then it would probably be able to detect both the original and
tranformed characteristics of a person from the same hair.  

  -Corinth, who just discovered this group and is thrilled to learn
she is not the only person who obsesses over details of a fictional
universe.






More information about the HPforGrownups archive