Sirius and the Witch's Hump
cindysphynx
cindysphynx at home.com
Wed Mar 6 00:39:15 UTC 2002
No: HPFGUIDX 36062
This is one of those questions that has probably been discussed
before, but I can't remember the answer, so here it is again. :-)
In PoA, Sirius gains entry to the castle twice. He does this (I've
always thought) by entering Honeydukes and entering and exiting the
castle through the witch's hump.
In Snape's Grudge, Harry sprints through the Honeydukes tunnel to
get back to the castle quickly. He "reached the inside of the
witch's hump, tapped it with his wand, stuck his head through, and
hoisted himself out; the hump closed . . ."
If a wand is required to open the witch's hump from the outside or
the inside, then how is Sirius managing this? Sirius clearly
doesn't have a wand, as he spends the last chapters of the book
using other people's wands. If a wand is not required to open the
witch's hump from the inside, then why does Harry do it when he is
in such a hurry to get back to the castle?
Similarly, once Sirius is inside the castle, how does he get out if
the witch's hump closes automatically?
So . . . how is Sirius getting into the castle?
Cindy
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive