Puffskein

judyserenity judyshapiro at earthlink.net
Thu Mar 7 16:40:44 UTC 2002


No: HPFGUIDX 36159

Amy and Elkins were discussing the "margin note" in Fantastic Beasts, 
where it says Fred used Ron's pet puffskein for bludger practice. 

Amy said:
> > However, I am never going to forgive Fred for killing Ron's 
> > puffskein, or JKR for thinking that that is funny (FB).

Elkins agreed:
> I refuse to believe that the same woman who wrote PoA could fail to 
> comprehend the gravity of killing someone's pet.  And since I don't 
> believe for a minute that Fred is *that* evil, I remain convinced 
> that it must have happened due to a terrible, horrible, gruesome 
> error of judgement, and not as a premeditated act of pet murder.

I was shocked when I read that in Fantastic Beasts, too.  But maybe 
Fred didn't kill it?  Maybe the puffskein just got royally ticked off 
and ran away, and that's why Ron didn't have it anymore?

Judy, who's starting to wonder if Fred is George's "evil twin". 





More information about the HPforGrownups archive