[HPforGrownups] JKR's Plot hole

[Katze]

No: HPFGUIDX 36176

roseswicegood wrote:
> 
> I hope this has not been covered before--does anyone know what the
> plot hole was that JKR had to fix in GoF?

Rowling won't tell us. She says that it would give too much away. I
think it actually do to do with Moody. And she ended up making him
Crouch at the end to make "someone" the bad guy. 

> On another topic, my teen (not a real HP fan) said--why couldn't
> Moody/Crouch turn anything into a port key like from his office?
> *My* response :-) as I always have one, was that a port key would not
> work inside Hogwarts and thus the Tournament had to be held on the
> quidditch field.  Please no angry words if this has been covered, I'm
> new here.
> Rose Swicegood
> 
> *to JKR:  please bring back Remus Lupin...

Lupin will be back in book 5 and book 7, and hopefully alive in the
epilogue.

-Katze