Is Hogwarts Public or Private? (I was using the American version of the word
siriuskase
siriuskase at yahoo.com
Thu Mar 14 18:31:46 UTC 2002
No: HPFGUIDX 36532
HOLLYDAZE:
> In the Us (as I understand) a public school is one paid for by
taxes and a Private school is on paid for by parents,
scholarships etc. In Britain, Public and Private schooling means
that SAME THING, they are both Fee paying schools.>
I was reading old posts and saw yours that had gone with no
response. Pardon me if I'm breaking some rule about
responding to old messages.
Americans would call Hogwarts a "statewide residential magnet
school for students with a strong aptitude" in the magic arts.
I copied this almost verbatom from the website of one:
http://www.ncssm.edu/
That one is supported by taxes and would be called public.
We don't know who pays for Hogwarts, it's never been
mentioned, but since Fred (or was it George) complains about
the cost of books, but not tuition, I think it is public in the
American sense.
>
> HOLLYDAZE!!!( Who personally -even though I'm British-
agrees with the American wording, it makes more sense).
The British terminology refers to the origin of the students. Any
family may apply for their child to be admitted to a Public School.
Private schools in great Britain are less formal, more like
apprenticeships or private tutoring or home schooling with a
teacher directly hired by the parents. But, I'm an American, I don't
guarantee my definition for correctness.
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive