[HPforGrownups] Arabella Figg - Animagus??

Sirius Kase siriuskase at yahoo.com
Sat Mar 16 21:34:44 UTC 2002


No: HPFGUIDX 36634

--- Ms Lizard Gizzard <lizgiz1980 at yahoo.com> wrote:

> > Amongst the weirdest rumours I have heard is the
one that Mrs Arabella Figg is an animagus, Crookshanks
to be exact.
> > 

> I've seen this one bandied about on the kids' sites.
I'll give the same argument here that I've made there.
Crookshanks is a *boy* cat!  As far as I have seen,
there is no evidence that transfiguration also results
in a sex change.  

> Liz Giz
> 

There has been one transgender transfiguration.  That
was between the two Crouches using polyjuice, not
animagic.  I don't know enough about the theory of
magic to know whether the process of becoming an
animagi has anything in common with the use of
polyjuice to transform.  But, it is a common
speculation that Hermione would be a cat, so I'm just
extrapolating that idea a little further.






More information about the HPforGrownups archive