wand order

oboakk nesbitaa at purdue.edu
Tue Mar 19 02:36:10 UTC 2002


No: HPFGUIDX 36654

Meg wrote:
> I have a very recent US copy of GoF. The word never is in the scar 
comment but the wand order is incorrect (James comes out first). Did 
I just manage to pick up an old copy or does anyone else with a 
recent US copy have the same thing? 
> I am so extremely confused.
> 

I also have a fairly new US copy and it has the same 'error'.  I read 
somewhere (I thought it was in the HP Lexicon, but I can't seem to 
find it right now), that the Lily/James order was 'corrected' and 
then 're-corrected' in later editions so that James does come out 
first.  JKR supposedly said that James did die first, but the order 
in the book is correct.  The author of this article theorized that 
maybe something about Harry, e.g. his desire to see his father, 
caused the wand order to be reversed.  

Did anyone else read this?  If so, do you remember where the 
information was?  I know I'm just not making this up....I hope.

Abby






More information about the HPforGrownups archive