Justafiable Means and Good using the Tools of Evil to Fight

finwitch finwitch at yahoo.com
Wed Mar 20 15:18:24 UTC 2002


No: HPFGUIDX 36737

--- In HPforGrownups at y..., "abigail_draconi" <chynarose8 at h...> wrote:
> Here is a semi-random question that entered my brain one fine Wen
> moring. Is there a true, clear line between Good and Evil? Does a
> means considered 'Evil' (use of 'dark' magic and artifacts)
> automatically become good just because the 'Good' side uses it? And
> who's to say that they are on the side of 'Good' in the first place?
> After all, I'm sure that V's convinced 100% Right.
> @--->-- Chyna Rose

Unforgivable Curses. *real* Moody never used them, even after one 
Crouch authorised it. Crouch was not good- neither one of them, 
although the son was worse. None of the "good" side has EVER used one 
of them.

Dementors. They are NOT good beings.

Baddies consider obedience a virtue, goodies don't. (and I'm NOT sure 
which side Snape belongs to!)





More information about the HPforGrownups archive