Privit Drive Safety Zone
grey_wolf_c
greywolf1 at jazzfree.com
Thu Mar 21 21:28:45 UTC 2002
No: HPFGUIDX 36822
--- In HPforGrownups at y..., "sophia mclaughlin" <sophiamcl at h...> wrote:
>
> There has been a discussion as to the nature of the Safety Zone at Privit=
> Drive. Did I really miss something, or is it anywhere clearly stated that=
> Privit Drive was a safety zone from MAGIC? All evidence points to the
> contrary, considering all the magic that does take place there. Isn't the=
re
> anyone else out there who thinks the safety zone applies exclusively to
> Voldemort´s power?
>
> Sophia
There is actually no canon to support the idea of a Safety Zone at all
except for Dumbledore's typical cryptic statements of Harry having to
go to live to his uncle's house for his protection.
>From then on, the members of this board (myself included) have gone on
to weave theories about this protection and how it's brought about. I
for one believe that most of the protection is some sort of mild
Fidelius mantained by Mrs. Arabella Figg (she would be the secret
keeper), but unfortunatelly this has great holes in it: we have no
knoledge of this "mild Fidelius", and it cannot be the normal one since
any number of people are able to find the house (unless the fidelius is
directed at pecific individuals, which I find highly unlikely).
Another possibility is that Mrs. Figg is a very powerfull DADA
professional and if Voldemort, in his debilitated state had come to pay
a visit, she would have "prodded serious buttock" (in words of Terry
Pratchett). This has also a big hole: V is not debilitated anymore, and
Harry has gone, nontheless, to privit drive for the summer once more at
the end of book 4.
Thus the situation stands. For other theories, search the archives (I
will not explain other people's theories for fear of getting them
wrong)
Hope that helps,
Grey Wolf
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive