Polyjuice workings/Azkaban's location
grey_wolf_c
greywolf1 at jazzfree.com
Fri Mar 22 17:40:40 UTC 2002
No: HPFGUIDX 36854
> Eloise:
> Which brings me back to the problems I always have with Mrs Crouch. How on
> earth did a dying woman manage that? It's hard enough to believe that she
> actually managed to drink some within an hour of death, without adding
> problems of preparation.
>
> Eloise
Dementors are blind, and cannot distinguish between humans. They sensed
a human inside the cell, and that was good enough for them (you don't
play with your food, nor argue with it, and that's what dementors think
of human: we aren't alive, were just the coffee-machine that serves
their snacks: feelings). I think that when Mrs. Criuch died, one of the
dementors just took her out to the back garden and buried her (or threw
her into the sea, or whatever). I don't imagine that many DE receive
visits while in Azkaban (Sirius receided one visit in 12 years, and he
was important), so no human actually noticed the change.
While on the subject, the Lexicon places the prison of Azkaban in an
island in the North sea. However, when I recently re-read PoA, Sirius
mentions that he was near Privet Drive because "Couldn't pass up the
opportunity of looking up Harry **before starting his trip North**"
(trip towards Hogwarts were he knew he could find Peter)(liberal
translation form my own language). I don't think that Sirius had that
much free time that he could cross twice England (from North to South
and back again) just for the pleasure of Harry's company. I think it
would fit better that Azkaban was in the Sea SOUTH of England, and thus
Sirius just had to make a small de-tour to visit Harry. Another point
is that we know that Sirius scapes the prison one or two days before
Harry runs away from Privet Drive (it's still fresh news: the Dursleys
act mildly surprised about it), and it would take Sirius' dog form
quite a bit longer to reach a beach and get to London if starting from
the North, but would be quite easier to do so from the South. I suppose
he could have apparated, but we have no canon evidence of Sirius
knowing how to apparate (although why then he has to run to Hogwarts in
dog form instead of just apparating in Hogsmeade escapes me).
In conclusion: I believe Azkaban is actually in an island south of
England (isle of man? my geography, specially the one outside my
country, is not very extense)
Anyway, I'm sure there must be a few holes in the theory, so let me
know what you feel about it. I would be grateful if someone could
actually find the original text for me (it's PoA, ch. "Wormtail,
Prongs, Moony, Padfoot", I think)
Hope that helps,
Grey Wolf
(He who started writting this post preocupied because it was going to
be a one-liner. ALso, he who was VERY wrong)
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive