Harry's Height /Cho's a midget?
serenadust
jmmears at prodigy.net
Fri Mar 22 22:35:03 UTC 2002
No: HPFGUIDX 36862
--- In HPforGrownups at y..., Ms Lizard Gizzard <lizgiz1980 at y...> wrote:
>
> I know Harry's probably not big for his age, owing to
> the Dursley's treatment of him, but do you really
> think he's that short? Most of the 13 year olds I
> know are in the 5' to 5'6" range.
My 11 year old son is in the 50% range for his age and is almost
exactly 5' tall. In the beginning of CofS it states, "Harry,
thought still rather small and skinny for his age, had grown a few
inches over the last year." (Chapter 1, CofS). So my assumption is
that if 5' is average for an 11 year old boy, then Harry would be in
the range of 5'3" for a "rather small" 13 year old (since boys in
the 11 to 13 y.o. range seem to do quite a bit of growing). What
has always seemed very wierd to me was that in Chapter 13 of the
same book Cho Chang is described as being shorter than Harry by
about a head. Most girls are close to their eventual adult height
by the age of 14 (she's a year older than Harry, right?). I'm
mortified to admit that I measured my 13 year old daughter's head
(didn't tell her why, of course, since she already has her doubts
about my sanity), and it's about 8 1/2 inches long. This would
indicate to me that Cho is only about 4 1/2' tall! Since she's a
seeker I would expect that she would be relatively small, but
wouldn't this make her almost freakishly short? I wonder if JKR
thought this through.
Jo Serenadust, feeling kind of stupid even bringing this up, but
wanting to know if anyone else has thought about this
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive