House elf Ownership/possesion
finwitch
finwitch at yahoo.com
Sun Mar 24 21:10:35 UTC 2002
No: HPFGUIDX 36930
--- In HPforGrownups at y..., "Amanda" <editor at t...> wrote:
> If the elves belonged to the families, their would not need to be a
House
> Elf Relocation Office. I think there is a complex bond, a 3-way
> relationship, involving the elf, the location, and the owner of the
> location. Status as the owner of the location gives the owner
certain powers
> over the elf, and the elves are bound to obey not the wizard per
se, but the
> owner of their location. For Winky, Mr. Crouch had the power to
free her,
> but what he did was banish her from her location, and her service
to its
> owners.
>
> Why else, then, would they be associated as strongly with places as
with old
> families? The Weasleys are an old wizarding family themselves.
>
> --Amanda,
Yes... Belonging to a place. Goes much like old folk-tales here. If
Dobby was house-elf to the Potter-house that was *exploded* by Evil
Voldemort, thus freeing Dobby from *place*. Harry, a minor, was the
*only* one left of the *family*. A possible solution for Winky&Dobby
becoming happy together, would be if Harry or Sirius bought Crouch
Manor and brought the two with him. Get Sirius free and live in
Crouch's old Manor!
"Finwitch"
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive