Good/Bad characters

[serenadust]

No: HPFGUIDX 38354

--- In HPforGrownups at y..., "cygnusff" <cygnusff at y...> wrote:


> Crouch Sr, Trelawney, Fudge, and Draco and friends are interesting 
> cases. Trelawney seems self-obsessed rather than plain nasty; she 
> might not do many 'good' things, but I can't see any 'evil' things 
> she's done either (as opposed to plain annoying). Crouch Sr. does 
> show some good motives (although only when he really has no other 
> choice). Fudge - I agree, it's hard to categorise him. Draco and 
> friends; well, at this moment it seems to me that Draco is heading 
> Lucius' way, but as I'm a controversial evil!Draco-theorist in the 
> same line as Keith Fraser, I'll leave this one out.


I'm pretty suspicious of Trelawney.  She's been portrayed as a total 
flake overall, who doesn't seem to have the respect of any of her 
colleagues, or of the students (other than Parvati & Lavender).  She 
always seems to delight in demoralizing Harry in particular, but 
when she made her *real* prediction about the dark lord rising, I 
began to wonder.  No one but death eaters ever seem to refer to him 
as the dark lord.

What is a controversial evil!Draco-theorist?  Have I missed a 
thread? I thought that evil Draco was pretty much canon.  Is canon 
controversial now?

Jo Serenadust