[HPforGrownups] Re: TBAY: Exorcizing the Prank

[Betty Landers]

No: HPFGUIDX 38814


Marina snipped
Irene:
Let's try for something more Bangy then. It's not Snape whom Sirius 
tried to kill that night, it's Remus who was supposed to die.
Sirius says that Snape knew lots of curses when he started Hogwarts, 
so he must have been quite well armed by his fifth year. I bet there 
is some "magical" way to kill werewolf besides the silver bullet.
So, what Sirius was doing sending this dangerous person to meet 
his "best friend"? He'd really counted on Snape to succeed, hadn't 
he - judging how he still hates him for failing after all those years.

That would be quite Bangy in my book. :-)

*It would indeed.  And pardon my saying so this bluntly, but it's also
patently rediculous.  If PPW were becoming/had already become animagi
*for Remus*, then why would Sirius want to have him *killed?  No way.  I
wouldn't buy that one for a penny.