[HPforGrownups] Should Saw It?

[mlacats at aol.com]

No: HPFGUIDX 38857

In a message dated 05/15/2002 12:51:31 PM Pacific Daylight Time, 
Chelsea2162 at aol.com writes:


> McGonagall should've realized then that although Moody was a tad (alright, a 
> 
> but more than a tad) paranoid, and he acted first and thought later, but 
> honestly, he was BOUNCING a student! He was causing a student to repeatedly 
> 
> slam into a stone floor! As soon as I read that, i knew that something was 
> up.
> Also, Crouch/Moody knew exactly what had happened with the Goblet...true, 
> some people may say that the other teachers just figured he was taking an 
> educated guess, and thinking along the lines of the "bad guys" but he 
> actually SAID the EXACT thing that he had done in order to trick the 
> Goblet! 
> Anyone have any thoughts? Or notice anything amiss?
> 

Although I did think the fake Moody's treatment of Malfoy was a bit 
over-the-top, I still didn't put two and two together the first time I read 
GOF...I just thought that Moody was very essentric and that everyone else 
would think so too.  As for what Moody said in the adjoining room after 
Harry's name came out of that goblet....well, I figured he was very wise and 
had it figured out and that the others should have realized the same 
thing....  My son was really surprised too.  Of course, it makes sense 
now......

Harriet - (Sorry, I don't post very often, but this was a very interesting 
take on the fake Moody)


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]