Are The Schoolbooks Canon? (WAS The Night The Jobberknoll Screamed)

[cindysphynx]

No: HPFGUIDX 38938

I wrote:

> > I wonder about one thing, though.  Has anyone ever
> > found any way in 
> > which the schoolbooks are consistent with the first
> > four books?

Heidi replied, right off the top of her head without so much as 
cracking a book:

> They're consistent in at least 4 places:

<snip impressive list of consistencies> 

Uh oh.  Ooops!  I had a little slip of the finger there.

I meant *inconsistencies*.  I mean, places where JKR messed up and 
put something in the schoolbooks that doesn't square with canon in 
the first four books.  

Sorry, Heidi.

Cindy (finally confessing in public that she has never even 
*read* "Quiddich Through The Ages", and who seems to have misplaced 
her only copy)