[HPforGrownups] Murder spree

Chelsea2162 at aol.com Chelsea2162 at aol.com
Tue May 28 18:44:45 UTC 2002


No: HPFGUIDX 39128

James writes:

<Well whilst reading Elkins' last post (and it's always lovely to have 
<someone recall a post that you thought was dead - not to mention 
<agree with your musings) I had a thought.  What are the stories 
<really about?  Good vs Evil?  The Rise and fall of Voldemort?  A boy 
<coming of age?  Harry's life?  Well that last one seems interesting.  
<First chapter, first book, famously re-written ad nauseam, title?  
<The boy who lived.

<What if he doesn't.

<There is no need for him beyond p.1 book seven.




While this is an interesting thought, I just can't imagine the books going on 
without Harry. They're about Harry, from his point of view, and center 
primarily on Harry's feelings and thought. While JRK does surprise us often, 
and while she did ask why we were so sure that Harry would live through the 
whole series, i really can't see the books without him. Without Harry, 
there'd be no series

*Chelsea*




More information about the HPforGrownups archive