'Potter Line' theory problem
ingachristsuperstar
ingachristsuperstar at yahoo.com
Fri Nov 1 21:28:25 UTC 2002
No: HPFGUIDX 46003
OK, I've always been partial to the idea that Voldie was going
after the "Potter Line" in total because he believed they posed
him some kind of specific threat (as the descendents of
Gryffindor or otherwise). I've liked it because it explains a lot of
the 'loose ends' floating around the series, like why LV was
willing to spare Lily.
But I just realized a problem with this. Within this theory, sparing
Lily would make no sense.
Why? - Because how did LV know that Lily wasn't pregnant?
It doesn't seem like he took the time to perform any spell to
check (if there is such a spell I don't think I'd like to know what
it
would involve) - he just stormed in and told her to stand aside.
Since Harry heard his father and mother die within a few
seconds of each other while under the Dementor's influence,
and we don't hear LV say anything like a spell, it doesn't seem
he stopped to check.
Now, I guess it would be possible for LV to count on his spy
(spies?) to let him know if Lily turned out to be pregnant and go
back and get that baby!Potter too, but wouldn't this be a pretty
inefficient way of doing things? Why not take care of that
possibility at the same time? After all, he killing Cedric when it
was convenient and in his interest without pausing to think
about.
Was he that sure that Wormtail would know _right away_ if she
was pregnant? Would this just be an inappropriate topic for a
children's book? (pregnancy less appropriate than murder, that
would be interesting :-) )
Or was LV going after James and Harry specifically rather than
after 'The Potters'? And if so, why? Is a new theory in order?
-Ing
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive