Antichrist!(insert main character here)

[jastrangfeld]

No: HPFGUIDX 46356

--- In HPforGrownups at y..., "Melody" <Malady579 at h...> wrote:
Melody:
> Um, I am not quite sure what you were getting at with the last bit
> about Snape, but Anti-Christ!Dumbledore...hmmm...interesting.
> Interesting.  He has been perceived as almost "god-like".  And GoF 
is
> the turning book of the series, so he has fit that pattern.  He 
looses
> in the death and resurrection part of the anti-christ though.  


Me:  Well maybe timewise right now . . . but if he *is* the death of 
year 5 . . . 

Melody:
Also,
> the anti-christ is good only to persuade the masses he is the one to
> rule the world.  Dumbledore has passed over that privilege.

Me:
hmm . . I also believe that he's supposed to be so humble at the 
beginning as to reject and simply help others, until he simply takes 
over?  At least that's kinda how they did it in the Left Behind 
series.

Melody:
> Also, the Foe-Glass comes to mind.  I firmly believe magical objects
> do not lie (maybe that is what I *want* to believe, but I see no
> reason for them to lie).  So since Dumbledore, Snape, and McGonagall
> were in the glass, and the glass belonged to Crouch Jr whose they 
saw
> as evil for taking Harry away from safety, I would say it is very
> clear that Dumbledore is not on evil's side.  Maybe that is a large
> jump and great assumption on my part, but to me it is very clear.

Me:
Ah yes, the foe glass . . . I've been wondering about that 
thing . . . just why did Snape have to peer into it?  I was trying to 
figure out if he normally doesn't have a reflection *hehehe* or if 
there were another reason that JK was trying to hint at . . . the 
beast for the antichrist? I guess my point about Snape is, is JK 
still trying to hint something to throw us off course from 
Dumbledore?  He looks at Snape with apprehension in his eyes when he 
sends him off for some mysterious task . . . We don't know why 
Dumbledore trusts him (again that little beast bit ;o) )  And look 
around, most close people to Dumbledore don't even question him, just 
go out and do the task, at least when it comes down to it.  If it's 
not so urgent, sure they put up their own little fights . . .


Just my opinion :o)

Julie