Who versus who
feumindra
saltwater at ev1.net
Sat Nov 9 04:53:28 UTC 2002
No: HPFGUIDX 46363
If I may, I'd like to suggest my own theory of at least one person
who would 'face off'...
Sylversong, you were wondering who Hermione would face off with, I
would submit to you that it is possible that Hermione may find
herself confronting DRACO...and I base this on the Egyptian mythology
model. In Egyptian mythos, it is the cat, BAST, who defeats the
serpent monster Apophis, and does so routinely. Hermione's familiar
is Crookshanks, a cat. NO familiar has been introduced for Draco,
other than his eagle owl, but as he is the 'ringleader' of the House
of Slytherin, whose emblem is the serpent, it is conceivable in my
mind that we may see Hermione confront/defeat/deflect any effort on
Draco's part in the future.
I refer you to Prisoner of Azkaban where, after Draco has been
particularly vile towards Hagrid, Hermione takes the initiative to
soundly slap the boy in the face...and what is his reaction? After 2-
3 years of harassing Harry, the Boy Who Defeated Voldemort, an
extremely powerful wizard, AND after exhibiting such racism towards
someone he thinks is incapable of defending herself, Draco TURNS TAIL
AND RUNS without further ado! Cat defeats serpent.
Later, and it is only in passing acknowledgement, Hermione tells
Harry and Ron that the reason why she fell asleep on her books was
because she had been thinking about Malfoy.
A cat can be just as cunning as any serpent is thought to be, and the
fact that Hermione, with her known characteristics of constant
analysis, is actually putting Draco through the processes is NOT a
good sign for Draco...whatever the implications may be. Both of them
are very intelligent and clever, both of them could be equals on the
battlefield.
This, of course, leads me to observe that in GoF, Draco acts just as
oddly towards Harry, Ron and Hermione in the most traumatic event of
their young lives, seeing Deatheaters return to use Muggles as
playthings...and WARNS OFF the trio. I have several scenarios in
mind of why he would choose NOT to hand over Harry and Hermione over
to the deatheaters that instant, but I am hoping (desperately...what
was it y'all were saying about wanting characters we like to
succeed/survive???)
I am rambling though. If you couldn't tell, Draco is my favorite
character.
For the phoenix theme, y'all will now be subjected to yet another
Egyptophile, that land that was called Kemet (black earth) or KMT.
Y'all may have already covered this, but as I am still playing catch-
up, I will stick my neck out and throw in my own observations about
my favorite ancient culture (I have a degree in anthropology).
Actually, the Phoenix is a Grecian myth about an Egyptian God that
has some Persian roots. The Egyptians actually worshipped the Bennu
Bird, a heron like species. In my own amateurish meanderings through
ancient Egyptian cultures, glyphs and stories, I have seen listed
SEVERAL glyphs for several kinds of birds, BUT! there is only ONE
special glyp attributed to the Bennu bird, depicted as a rather
splendid heron with a great deal of detail. There is some
speculation that the species of heron that the bennu was from
actually existed, but died out long before the recording of history.
My thoughts are that it could have been a brightly colored heron,
something we are not used to seeing, as we are more familiar with the
Great Blue Heron that exists today (which by the way is also a very
splendid creature. My heart thrills every time I see one!) It is
possible that Persian elements enters here as a bird of firey gold
and red and beautiful plummage, but I am only making wild guesses
now.
I believe it was Herodotus who related the mythology of the Egyptian
bennu bird to the Greeks and refered to it as the Phoenix, a creature
that could recreate itself from ashes after a long life. In Egyptian
mythology, anthropologists/archaeologists hypothesize that this could
be a reference to the heron's morning habits of taking flight at
daybreak...or even to the appearance of the Morning Star, Venus.
It has been awhile since I have picked up those books, but I thought
these things were interesting to share. Hope y'all don't mind me
reiteriating what you already know!
As for Molly Weasley not working, I do hope the cold vacuum of
cyberspace does not lead y'all to take umbrage with my next offer,
but as a stay at home mother, I *do* feel the need to point this out:
it *is* possible that Molly stays at home BECAUSE SHE WANTS TO. I
realize there are quite a few other mothers in this list, and I do
not in any way wish to make an issue of whether or not you SHOULD or
SHOULD NOT work. I can only speak from my perspective as someone who
CHOOSES not to pursue a career and simply be someone to whom my
daughter can come home to after school.
I cringe at the modern day assumption many have that if a woman is
NOT out being SUPERwoman in career and motherhood and life etc, she
is not complete or worse, NOT a REAL WOMAN. Molly is the hub of the
wheel that is the Weasley family...all Weasley life seems to derive
its motion from her presence. Choosing to stay at home because she
is HAPPY there should not be out of the realm of consideration. Are
women so inured to the possibility of homelife as fulfilling as a
highpowered career that the idea that someone would WANT to stay home
is virtually impossible????
I'll get off my soap box now. Everyone I have read has had SO MANY
insightful, intelligent remarks and thoughts, I dont think I will
ever catch up. thank you for letting me join in!
best regards to everyone,
Sharon Ferguson
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive