[HPforGrownups] Harry sparing V'mort

[sugarkadi at aol.com]

No: HPFGUIDX 46422

Rich said:

"All a case of stooping to the level of the killers... Would it be
> right for us to torture and kill prisoners purely because that was
> what the enemy did to us? I say no..."
> 


If you did torture the person who tortured you I would say that that was 
morally wrong.  However, If Harry just kills LV and not all his supporters 
and doesn't crucio him, I don't really see that as Harry stooping to LV's 
level.  I can see the argument if he uses the AK spell, but maybe he'll use 
Gryffindor's sword.  


"Can anyone > see a speck of darkness on Harry? Probably.. Id like to know 
> what that is, tho :)"

Well, Harry *did* think that Black deserved the Dementors Kiss, even though 
it's worse than death.  


> "This (for me) brings up the question of how Wossisname (sorry Im tired
> and can't remember the name of Voldemorts predecessor as Evil Wizard
> of the Age) was defeated by Dumbledore.... Is D'dore tainted by an
> evil act?"

It's Grindlewald.  And maybe.  I don't have any thoughts on that.

~Katey





[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]