Question re The Riddle House
marephraim
htfulcher at comcast.net
Tue Nov 12 20:53:53 UTC 2002
No: HPFGUIDX 46526
Forgive me for this as I'm sure it _must_ have been discussed at
length before. My wife and I are now both on our fourth read of the
canon (for me this is since last Christmas, JRK hurry!).
In Chamber of Secrets Tom Riddle speaks of living in the orphanage
because his muggle father turned him and his mother out when he
discovered she was a witch. He also indicates that after Hogwarts he
disappeared (figuratively speaking) so that no one later realized
that Riddle and He Who Must Not be Named were one and the same
person.
In Goblet of Fire the deaths at the Riddle House included the
elderly Mr & Mrs Riddle and their grown up son, Tom.
Question: Is this a Flint? Are we to assume that the Tom Riddle of
CoS, because the distillation of his 15 year old self, could only
assume what he would do after leaving the school (the manner in
which the Diary was made and the potential personality limitations
on the TR who occupies its pages itself is thought provoking)?
Further, it seems the old saw that You Know Who is ALWAYS the
antagonist in HP books doesn't hold for CoS. Sure TR is the trouble
maker, but LM is the instigator. (I know I'm going to sound like a
dottering old fool for saying this but...) are LM's motives for the
diary truly clear in CoS? Did he intend revenge againt Harry,
revenge against the Weasley's? Revenge against m*dbl##ds at the
school? Was he somehow following He Who Must Not Be Named's wishes
(Imperius Curse)? -- although this latter one strikes me as highly
unlikely.
Again, forgive if this has been discussed before (and more so if the
FAQ, etc., cover it in detail). Remember reading those books four
times in a year is hard if you're tring to hold down a job and have
a meaningful muggle life on the side, too!
Thanks for any enlightenment on this ("Lumo!")
MarEphraim
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive