There's somthing about Trevor
Regina
rmm7e at yahoo.com
Wed Nov 13 15:39:03 UTC 2002
No: HPFGUIDX 46560
--- In HPforGrownups at y..., jazmyn <jazmyn at p...> wrote:
> I have a fish too.. a betta.. named Bob. Someone I know claimed to
have
> a Betta named Alpha...
<Raises hand.> We keep a tank here at work and until recently had a
Betta named Alpha. We thought we were so clever. Guess not.
Anyway, my take on the cat OR owl OR toad was that it was a clue that
Scabbers was not as he seemed. It bothered me from the beginning that
Ron was allowed to have him, and as soon as Scabbers' identity was
revealed, I immediately thought of the letter. I'm not saying he was
allowed because anybody suspected what he was, but rather that JKR
was simply giving a subtle clue.
Too subtle for me, though. When Scabbers was revealed I had a hard
time believing it. Sure, the Weasleys were a good wizarding family,
and having Arthur at the MoM was particularly helpful to Peter, but
what are the odds that Ron would become best friends with Harry?
*That* was just unbelievably lucky.
--Regina
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive