Slytherin, the Chamber and the Basilisk
David
dfrankiswork at netscape.net
Sat Nov 23 02:53:59 UTC 2002
No: HPFGUIDX 47005
Iris wrote:
>
> I don't know if this has been debated yet: why did Slytherin build
the Chamber of Secrets, on which purpose? Why did he hide the
Basilisk?
and went on to raise the possibility that Salazar Slytherin was
misunderstood by later followers and opponents.
Sorry to take so long to respond, but I have only just become aware
of this thread.
To my knowledge, this is not a topic that has been debated much.
I think it is interesting that the chamber is called the Chamber of
Secrets. What secrets? The only secrets we know of were the precise
identity of the 'monster within', and the location and mechanism of
the entrance.
Possibly the chamber was designed as a place for carrying out spells
(or spell) of unusual importance, and one of these would have
required a basilisk. (In which case Trevor's importance may be for
getting another one)
What might such a spell be? We know that Slytherin was concerned
about the admittance to Hogwarts of muggleborns - but not on grounds
of magical inferiority or hostility, just of security in an age of
persecution. A *magical* approach to this problem would be to try to
bring about some kind of reconciliation between wizards and muggles
by means of a spell.
Such an approach would of course be highly *ambitious*, and might not
appeal to the brave who would prefer to tough a situation out.
It is entirely plausible that it would also require a reconciled and
united wizarding world to be successful. Hence Slytherin could never
finish his 'noble work'.
So what we could be looking for is a wizard who unites Slytherin
characteristics with those of other houses, particularly Gryffindor,
who can speak Parseltongue, who knows where the Chamber of Secrets
is, and also has a foot in the muggle camp.
David
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive